Part 1 of this post talked about why I bothered to spend so many hours on this little pet project of mine (and why I decided to go ahead publish it) but the overwhelming reason was curiosity. What could I borrow from the Toronto Public Library, how could I find it and where were they deciding to put different series within their collections? It's a bit embarrassing to think about how much time I spent doing this, but what the heck. It was sort of fun in a making-a-list kind of way. :) Here is what I did and what I found.
The Searches:
No searches were done from the front search box. This is a general keyword type search, and pretty useless if you're looking for something specific. All searches were done by clicking the "Search" tab and using the drop down menu on the "Basic" screen or were done from the "Advanced Search" screen. The abbreviations in brackets are how each search is listed in the title list.
Graphic novels - advanced search - subject keywords - 1750 results - limited to remove Merrill Collection results - 882 results - 279 of these were manga titles (gn)
Tokyopop - basic search - publisher keyword - 158 results (tpop)
Viz - basic search - publisher keyword - 254 results - included books and dvd's in results (viz)
Graphic Novels — Japan - basic search - subject begins with - 111 results - these also seemed to be included in the broader graphic novels search (gn-jp)
Dark Horse - basic search - publisher keyword - 349 results - 97 of these were manga titles (dh)
ADV - basic search - publisher keyword - 25 results - 4 were manga titles, most were dvds (adv)
Manga - basic search - any keyword - 125 results - 32 of these were manga - picked up Dark Horse Manga as well (manga)
Other searchs:
Viz graphic novel - 103 results - series term clicked through from manga record - not saved or added to list because I generously assumed they would be included in the Viz as publisher search.
Graphic Novels — Korea - zero results - I found this subject in the catalogue in my home town. I thought it would be worth a try but Toronto doesn't seem to distinguish between manwha and manga. I didn't check all of them, but I don't remember there being any Korean graphic novels included in the Graphic Novels — Japan search.
The Oddities:
Examples of manga with no subjects:
Hellsing
Alice 19th (for volumes 4 and 6 only)
Ultra Maniac
Castle in the Sky
Tsubasa
xxxHolic
Most were found by publisher searches. The Del Rey titles were completely missed (and found either by an author or title search) as I am unwilling to browse through results for a search on Del Rey as publisher.
Imadoki has no volume numbers, only names.
Alice 19th - there are two author entries for Yu Watase within the Alice 19th records.
Ultra Maniac - two entries (vol. 1 and volume 1 as "other title"), only one for the author. Also listed as (television program) despite being a manga. Probably because the note says that it inspired the anime.
Tsubasa and xxxHolic - not found by searching Del Rey - one is listed with Clamp (artistic group) as author, the other Clamp. One xxxHolic record lists Tsubasa as the translated title of the book (I emailed the library about this). Othello and Wallflower were found as title searches. These all listed Kodansha within their records so I tried it as a keyword search, but there were 1300 results - too many to sift through.
Some titles are listed more than once in the catalogue because of spelling variations within the records. "Title volume xx" is given as a variant/alternate title while "Title vol. X" might be the main entry.
Removed from the List:
Any Pokemon titles - I didn't want to try to separate the manga from the chapter books and videos/dvds
NO Holdings - some of these were from the Merril collection, some were lost
Two art books kept on list on a whim
Reading the list:
Dragon Ball Z. Vol. 1-13
Toriyama, Akira, 1955-
Viz Communications, c1984.
Teen Graphic Books FICTION TOR
Graphic Books FICTION TOR
Children's Graphic Books FICTION TOR
(gn 1,12-13 ) (viz 1-13) (gn-jp vol 13)
The library holds volumes 1-13.
They are held in three different collections - Graphic Books, Teen Graphic Books and Children's Graphic Books
Volumes 1, 12 and 13 were in the "graphic novel" search results - volumes 1-13 were in the "viz" search results - volume 13 was in the "graphic novels - japan" search results.
V. Vol. Volume 1 One etc - records were emailed from the catalogue so abbreviations, numbers have not been changed.
Disclaimers:
The searches were run on May 2nd, May 17th and May 22nd. Records may have changed since then (ie manga on order will be catalogued and may then show up in different searches). This isn't a list of all the manga in the TPL system, just the ones I could find. WordPress also saw fit to remove much of the formatting from the list. Apologies if any bunching of titles was missed/is unfixable.
The List:
(more…)